Of Inner and Outer Voices

I recently had a revelation about a voice* that has haunted me since high school telling me if I don’t acheive certain goals such as passing exams, staying in paid work, fulfilling a role in society, my life is worthless and I don’t deserve to be here.

Mental health-wise I have been much better over the past year as a result of strength training and yoga and working on my spiritual development with my mentor Jayne Johnson. A few months ago for the first time I heard my healthy body saying ‘I want to live’ and this has helped me to combat the negative voice.

Yet I went through a difficult time after my attempt to write a novel for Gwyn failed and I realised I must truly give up my ambition to be a professional author (as I promised Him over ten years ago!). I ended up back at the Abyss with the choice between three gates – to live as I was, to die, or to change. I took the third gate.

During a period of prayer I discerned what to do next – return to outdoor work in horticulture and become a shamanic practitioner. So I started working towards those goals. I began studying for my RHS Level 2 in Horticulture and volunteering with Let’s Grow Preston. I applied for the Sacred Trust’s three year shamanic practitioner training and was over the moon when I was offered a place. However, the downside is the course and the train fares to Devon will cost all my savings and then some. 

The negative voice returned as I began to struggle with concerns about finding paid work in horticulture before my savings run out. Long term I am planning to start a nature-friendly gardening business but I am aware it will take a while to complete my training, set up, find clients and start earning. So I started applying for any outdoor work from plant nurseries and garden centres to grounds maintenance and also cleaning (which Gwyn advised me against). 

That week, the more jobs I applied for, the more I panicked, the louder the voice grew. Telling me I’m a fool to spend so much money on a course which is my soul’s calling but isn’t likely to help me earn much. Preventing me from meditating and journeying saying instead I should be applying for jobs. 

The afternoon before I attended a Radical Embodiment workshop** with Jayne and Alex Walker I had a terrible interview for a cleaning job. I arrived at the workshop scatty with the voice shouting loudly at me telling me the practices were pointless and worthless and wouldn’t help me find paid work.

I spent the first half, in the morning, battling against the voice. Then, in the afternoon, when I was more relaxed and present and connected with other bodies the voice stopped. When finally we came to dancing our insights I decided to have it out with the voice once and for all but found it had vanished.

I then received the gnosis – ‘It’s not my voice’. 

This was one of the most significant revelations of my life. For decades I thought it was a part of me, an inner critic, formed from my internalisation of the capitalist work ethic. A little like the inner Sheriff of Nottingham Nicola Smalley describes in The Path to Forgotten Freedom only a whole lot nastier.

Then, finally, it struck me, no part of my psyche would tell me I was worthless or want me dead. This voice differs from my true inner critic who, of course, is critical, can be harsh and judgemental, but is looking after my integrity.

I realised any voice inimical to my life is not my voice.

Then what is it? I began to wonder. I intuited it must be a malevolent entity. When I asked Gwyn He told me it was not one of the spirits of Annwn. I sensed it wasn’t from the underworld or any of the lower worlds but was bound up with the middleworld. Unlike the spirits of Annwn / ‘fairies’ who live in a reciprocal relationship with Thisworld but have their own independent world and reality it could not survive without parasitising upon human emotions.

Names that came to my mind were ‘liar’ and ‘deceiver’ which I remembered are applied to Satan ‘the Father of Lies’. Was I being tormented by the Devil?

When I asked one of my spiritual ancestors she replied that it was a malicious spirit, an ysbryd drygioni. Christians have blown such beings up into one big Devil in the same way they have raised Jahweh into one big God.

I asked whether I needed to hunt it down and destroy it (like Ged does the gebbeth in The Wizard of Earthsea – my experience reminded me of that story). My guide replied, ‘No’, as such beings feed on our attention and negative emotions. The best defences against it are to do the things it tells me not do because they will not help me gain a job and earn money – prayer, meditation, journeywork, sitting still in nature (which I really struggle with), being with other bodies, dancing, play and fun (which I never allow myself). 

Realising this voice isn’t mine and hearing how to defend myself from it are huge steps I am hoping will help me move forward towards earning a living in a way that allows me to stay physically and mentally well and fulfil my vocation.

I’d be interested to hear whether anyone else has had similar experiences. How do you tell the difference between inner and outer voices? I’m hoping to get to grips with such discernment processes better towards the end of my shamanic practitioner training when we approach practices such as depossession.

*Here I’m referring to intrusive thoughts not to auditory hallucinations.
**A development from embodied relational therapy.

7 thoughts on “Of Inner and Outer Voices

  1. Nimue Brown says:

    This is a huge breakthrough! All of the voices I’ve had that were not mine, were identifiably other people’s voices, but what you’re saying makes a great deal of sense to me. Treating is as a malevolent entity and warding it off by whatever means seems like a good way to go. Laughing at it might be worth a pop as well.

  2. ganglerisgrove says:

    I feel moved to add that you have not failed. You have learned and grown and sometimes I think that’s what the Gods want of us when They set us (or we are moved to set for Them) certain goals. and you ARE an author. Van Gogh, iirc from yr reading, never sold a painting while he lived yet he is certainly a damn fine painter. Your work stands as a testament of praise to your Gods in all its faltering humanness and that is a beautiful and even holy thing.

  3. Greg Hill says:

    I see the true inner voice as the soul, cherishing our deeper values (inherited and acquired) and our essential nature; the intrusive outer voice as the world as it is, governing the transient realities of material life. It is the soul that should inspire us to acheive what we aspire to do and to be, but the constraints the world imposes cannot be ignored any more than that they should be uncritically accepted. Because it is transient, material reality contains within it the potential for change, but that can only come about from where we are now rather than trying to move on from an ideal starting point. The deceiving voices are those that hide this from us and so set us up to fail. The gods call to the soul; it is for us to find sustainable ways to follow that call and not lose the way because we imagine we are starting from a point other than where we currently are. You have consistently and successfully followed the promptings of the soul and resisted the demands of the world. If Sustainability has been more difficult, perhaps you need to discern the viability of what you hope to do next and how sustainable the path you are considering will be. Whatever you choose, your inner resources are strong enough to maintain you and for you to find your own way.

    • lornasmithers says:

      Thanks for your reply Greg. I know what you mean about sustainability. Writing such niche books was never going to be sustainable. Neither was full time environmental work. I’m trying to head for a way between with part time work in horticulture supplemented with the very small income from my writing and hopefully with shamanic healings when I have passed the course.

  4. Thornsilver says:

    This feels like a huge realization and resonates with me a lot. I’ve been thinking a lot about ways to sustainably support myself in ways that don’t drain my happiness or energy. Thank you for sharing and I’m glad to be with you on this journey! And I’m going to send this to a friend who has similar struggles–it might help them as well. 🙂

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.